Rural Industries
Research & Development Corporation

|| Home || Search || Contact ||  Publications Eshop || Privacy Statement ||

RIRDC Completed Projects in 1999-2000 & Research in Progress as at June 2000
BACK TO INDEX
To Research in Progress
 

2.7 TEA TREE OIL
COMPLETED PROJECTS 1999-2000

PROJECT No
PROJECT TITLE
RESEARCHER
PHONE
ORGANISATION
CSF-55A Development of DNA markers for tea tree Dr John Doran 02 6281 8319 CSIRO Forestry & Forest Products
DAQ-252A Plant Nutritional Survey of the Australian Tea Tree Industry Dr James Drinnan 07 4092 8555 Qld Department of Primary Industries
UWA-51A Skin sensitivity testing for tea tree oil - second stage A/Professor Tom Riley 08 9346 3690 University of Western Australia
2.7 TEA TREE OIL
COMPLETED PROJECTS prior to 1999-2000
PROJECT No
PROJECT TITLE
RESEARCHER
PHONE
ORGANISATION
UWA-42A Skin Sensitivity Testing for Tea Tree Oil Dr J E Greig, Ms C F Carson, Dr M S Stuckey, A/Professor T V Riley 08 9346 3690 Department of Microbiology, The University of Western Australia 
UWA-24A The antimicrobial activity of tea tree oil A/Professor T V Riley 08 9346 3690 University of Western Australia
DAN-74A Herbicides for weed control in tea tree oil plantations Tony Cook 02 6763 1100 NSW Agriculture
DAN-91A Insect pest management in tea tree Gus Campbell 02 66280604 NSW Agriculture
US-20A Towards non-chemical control of weeds in tea tree J Murtagh, G Baker & J Doran 02 9692 2050 University of Sydney
DAN-87A Breeding and selection of Australian tea tree for improved oil yield and quality Dr I Southwell 02 6626 1104 NSW Agriculture
DAN-104A Significance of cineole for the bioactivity and irritancy of tea tree oil Dr I Southwell 02 6626 1224 NSW Agriculture
DAQ-184A Developing the North Queensland tea tree industry Dr J Drinnan 07 4092 8555 Queensland Department of Primary Industries
Project Title: Development of DNA markers for tea tree
RIRDC Project No.: CSF-55A
Researcher:  Dr John Doran & Dr Gavin Moran
Organisation: CSIRO Forestry & Forest Products
PO Box E4008
KINGSTON ACT 2604
Phone: 02 6281 8211
Fax: 02 6281 8266
Email John.Doran@ffp.csiro.au Gavin.Moran@ffp.csiro.au
Objectives To develop a dinucleotide microsatellite DNA library for tea tree and to characterise 10 microsatellite loci. The most useful microsatellite loci and primer sequences for fingerprinting breeding lines identified by this research will be documented in a Commercial-in-Confidence report to the RIRDC /ATTIA Tea Tree Breeding Project meeting of August 2000.
Background DNA markers provide a means of monitoring pollen flow and assessing the level of contamination in seed orchards, testing the validity of controlled crosses, of identifying selfs and fingerprinting clones. The study of genetic segregation in full-sib progenies allows genetic linkage maps to be constructed. These maps provide a framework in which genes of economic or practical significance can be located. The RIRDC.ATTIA tea tree breeding project will produce the first highly improved seed from its orchards in 2000. Unrestricted access to its own DNA markers, as provided by this project, to monitor the distribution and use of this seed and any clones released by the project will be a powerful deterrent to the misuse of this material, vital to the future of the industry in Australia.
Research  Twenty-three microsatellite loci have been characterised in Melaleuca alternifolia. These microsatellites have been grouped into 6 multiplexes for efficient use in applications in the breeding program. The microsatellites showed mendelian segregation in controlled crosses. The eight parental breeding clones were typed for their DNA genotypes at the loci and could be distinguished from each other on the genotypes on the just the first two loci. These genotypes were used to certify ramets against ortets of several other breeding clones and some ramets were found to be incorrect.
Outcomes  Twenty-three microsatellite loci are now available for use in the breeding of M. alternifolia.

DNA fingerprinting of ramets of breeding clones has revealed errors in labelling ramets used in a breeding arboretum, confirming the value of the technique in quality control.

The assays of progeny from controlled crosses without emasculation have shown that significant levels of selfed seed can occur. This needs to be tested across a number of females.

Implications Microsatellites can now be used to routinely to monitor for quality control in the breeding program. Production of selfed seed in controlled crosses without emasculation suggests that this method may have limited application in breeding programs.
Publications Commercial-in-Confidence report to RIRDC/ATTIA Tea Tree Breeding Committee

 
 
Project Title: Plant Nutritional Survey of the Australian Tea Tree Industry
RIRDC Project No.: DAQ-252A
Researcher:  James Drinnan
Organisation: Queensland Department of Primary Industries
PO Box 1054
MAREEBA QLD 4880
Phone: (07) 4092 8555
Fax: (07) 4092 3593
Email
DrinnanJE@dpi.qld.gov.au,
Objectives
(1) Determine the current nutritional status and corresponding yields of tea tree grown in Australia (North Queensland and Northern New South Wales).

(2) Determine some ballpark optimum fertiliser recommendations for tea tree.

(3) Improve the knowledge base of the Australian producers on the nutritional requirements of tea tree.

Background The Australian tea tree industry is likely to face strong competition from low cost overseas producers in the near future. Also, unless the demand for tea tree oil continues to increase rapidly to meet increasing supply there is likely to be pressure on the price of tea tree oil. Given these circumstances, producers must reduce their costs of production. One area highlighted by RIRDC (98/99 key issue) and the Australian Tea Tree growers association to help achieve this is to determine the nutritional requirements for maximising yields. In high production areas such as north Queensland - where water, temperature and radiation are not limiting and soils are relatively infertile, and in NSW on less fertile soils or where soil fertility has declined (due to a number of cropping cycles), nutrition is considered one of the major limitations to increased yields. By conducting this nutritional survey the range in types and amounts of fertiliser being used and the relationship with yields can be assessed.
Research  A survey was conducted of growers in QLD and NSW to determine current fertiliser practices (types and quantities) and the biomass and oil yields achieved. Leaf and soil analysis results were collected, collated and analysed. Information on soil type and fertility, irrigation levels, leaf drop and plant size at harvest was also collected. An estimate of fertiliser requirement was made by calculating nutrient removal in the biomass.
Outcomes  This project has increased the knowledge base of the nutritional requirements of tea tree. The survey has documented the current nutritional status of the Australian Tea Tree Industry. While the survey indicated little correlation between fertiliser inputs and oil yield, this may be due to the variety of factors which influence yield. However, a conservative approach and one which will apply in the long term is to use sufficient fertiliser to replace the nutrients removed at harvest. Results have indicated the amounts, types and timing of fertiliser being used and the range in yields being achieved. The optimal leaf and soil nutrient levels established provide a guide for growers to assess their fertiliser practices. From nutrient removal calculations it is recommended growers in QLD use around 180 kg N, 20 kg P and 220 kgK/ha/year and in NSW 130 kg N, 15 kg P and 158 kgK/ha/year. This should be applied regularly in small amounts throughout the growing season in approximately the following proportions - 10% from 0-2, 20% from 2-4 months, 20% from 4-6 months following harvest and 50% from 6 months after harvest until the trees are harvested again.

 
Project Title: Skin sensitivity testing for tea tree oil - second stage
RIRDC Project No.: UWA-51A
Researcher:  Associate Professor Thomas V Riley
Organisation: University of Western Australia
Dept of Microbiology
Queen Elizabeth II Medical Centre
NEDLANDS WA 6009
Phone: (08) 9346 3690
Fax: (08) 9346 2912
Email triley@cyllene.uwa.edu.au
Objectives To further assess skin sensitivity to tea tree oil and its major components in vivo.
Background The continued marketing of tea tree oil as a safe topical antimicrobial agent requires firm proof of the claims made as the industry expands into overseas markets such as the USA. In the case of safety information, such data is lacking. Our work to date (Previous project UWA-42A) has indicated that allergy to tea tree oil is quite rare, whilst irritation may be a more common problem. By investigating not only the frequency, but also more specifically the cause and characteristics of reactions, it will be possible for the industry to improve both the project and the available relevant information.
Research Patch testing was again used to further assess the threshold for reactions in individuals who had allergic reactions previously. In addition, the ability of excipients to ameliorate any allergic reactions was also assessed. Subjects included those who were shown to be allergic in previous research plus additional individuals. 

The affect of storage conditions on adverse events due to changes in component levels was evaluated by exposing oil to heat, light and air.

Outcomes The results suggest that oxidation products of tea tree oil, rather than individual components of fresh tea tree oil, are responsible for allergic reactions to the oil. Thresholds for reactions to pure oil also varied between individuals, ranging from 0.5% to 10%. No responses were seen in the absence of tea tree oil. Most individuals reacted to the same extent as previously. Oils stored in clear as opposed to brown bottles showed marked changes. An evaluation of tea tree oil poisoning is in progress.
Implications Tea tree oil adverse reactions are at least partially due to oxidation products suggesting additional recommendations for storage may be required. These data also have implications for dermatologists who may be asked to patch test individuals, particularly in relation to the age of the test oil. Those individuals with low tea tree oil thresholds should avoid tea tree oil completely. Tea tree oil reactions are unlikely to be reduced by most excipients.

 


COMPLETED PROJECTS prior to 1999-2000

Please note, researchers contact details were correct when submitted but may not still be current

Project Title Skin sensitivity testing for tea tree oil
RIRDC Project No.: UWA-42A
Researchers:  Dr J E Greig, Ms C F Carson, Dr M S Stuckey, A/Prof T V Riley
Organisation: Department of Microbiology, The University of Western Australia 
and Division of Microbiology and Infectious Diseases, PathCentre
Queen Elizabeth II Medical Centre, 
NEDLANDS WA 6009
Phone: 08 9346 3690
Fax: 08 9346 2912
Email:  triley@cyllene.uwa.edu.au
Objectives
· To evaluate the ability of tea tree oil and its major components to cause skin sensitivity.
Background For almost 80 years, tea tree oil has been marketed as a safe and efficacious topical antimicrobial agent. While there is sufficient scientific evidence showing its antimicrobial properties in vitro, data supporting its safety remain limited, fragmented and largely anecdotal. Although adverse reactions appear to occur relatively infrequently, a number of cases of contact dermatitis to tea tree oil have been reported. Yet there is little information available regarding the frequency and reasons for these allergic or irritant reactions.
Research  The research involved testing over 200 healthy volunteers for allergy to tea tree oil using two different tests. Ten tea tree oils were tested to determine whether there would be any difference in reactions. 

The prick test involves an immediate allergic reaction. It is the type of test used in the diagnosis of grass and dust-mite allergy amongst other things, and we tested these allergens as well as tea tree oil in order to determine if our volunteer population was more or less allergic than average. 

The patch test detects a delayed reaction that develops on the skin surface. It is used to diagnose allergic contact dermatitis, but sometimes causes an irritant reaction. There are some substances that commonly cause allergic dermatitis. 

We tested the volunteers to some of these in addition to tea tree oil in order to determine their overall reactivity in this type of test. Any volunteer who exhibited a reaction to tea tree oil was tested again with 100% oil, 10% oil and oil components.

Outcomes  The volunteers ranged in age from 18 to 82 years, with an average age of 40. Women made up 61% of the group, and 63% of volunteers were sure of having previously used tea tree oil.

The tests for immediate allergy indicated that while we had an overly reactive group of people, only 1.4% of people (3 of 219) displayed any reaction to tea tree oil, and reactions were to only 1 or 2 of 10 oils. 

The volunteers also appeared to be slightly more reactive to contact allergens than might be expected. A total of 52 of the 219 volunteers displayed some reaction to tea tree oil although, in a number of these people, this consisted only of a questionable reaction to 1 or 2 of the 10 oils. Secondary testing was performed on 33 volunteers. Results were classified as allergic contact dermatitis, mild or marked irritant contact dermatitis, indistinguishable between allergy and irritancy, or no response. 

The prevalence of allergy in the whole group was 2.9% up to a possible 4.8% if indistinguishable is included. To have an allergy requires a previous exposure to the substance being tested, and the levels of allergy amongst those who had previously used tea tree oil was 4.6% up to a possible 7.6% including the indistinguishable reactions. The prevalence of marked irritancy to 100% tea tree oil ranged from 2.4-4.3% (with or without the indistinguishable reactions), with any level of irritancy ranging from 7.2-10.1%. Irritant reactions are particularly concentration dependent, which means that many of these reactions should be avoidable if a lower concentration of oil is used. Very few reactions occurred in response to tea tree oil components, with a single mild response to each of 2 components, and 4 significant reactions to another component.

Implications  While the prevalence of irritant or allergic reactions to tea tree oil is low, it is clear that a small proportion of people may experience adverse effects, especially if 100% oil is used. This information will allow appropriate marketing of the product for safe usage.
Project Title The antimicrobial activity of tea tree oil
RIRDC Project No.: UWA-24A
Researcher:  Assoc. Professor T. V. Riley
Organisation: Department of Microbiology
The University of Western Australia
Queen Elizabeth II Medical Centre
NEDLANDS WA 6009 
Phone: (08) 9346 3690
Fax: (08) 9346 2912
Background Despite the increasing interest in tea tree oil for therapeutic purposes, the vast majority of reports of its efficacy in treating a variety of infections are anecdotal and there is a paucity of information in appropriate peer-reviewed journals. This situation constitutes a significant dilemma for the tea tree oil industry. Early submissions to the Food and Drug Administration in the United States of America for tea tree oil to be registered as an over-the-counter topical antimicrobial have not been successful. One reason for this is that published in vitro efficacy data were lacking.
Research  Adequate data regarding the susceptibility of various pathogens to tea tree oil are required. Therefore, one of the first priorities was to accumulate substantial data on isolates from infections potentially treatable with tea tree oil. In addition, investigations into the antimicrobial activity of the individual components were required. The second area of research was a focus on the mechanism of action of tea tree oil, as no information on this area was available.
Outcomes  As a first step methods were developed and validated and finally, a broth micro-dilution method was used to examine the susceptibility of various bacteria. All bacteria tested were susceptible to tea tree oil with only one, Pseudomonas being slightly less susceptible. For example, methicillin-resistant strains of S. aureus (MRSA), an important cause of hospital-acquired infections was inhibited by 0.25% tea tree oil suggesting tea tree oil may be useful in the treatment of MRSA. Other studies indicated that tea tree oil, when formulated into appropriate products, may be useful in the treatment of bacterial vaginal infections. The antimicrobial activity of eight components of tea tree oil was evaluated using disc diffusion and broth microdilution methods. Terpinen-4-ol was active against all the test organisms while r -cymene demonstrated no antimicrobial activity. Linalool and a -terpineol were active against all organisms with the exception of Pseudomonas.

The Food and Drug Administration requires that the in vitro antimicrobial spectrum of compounds intended for use as a health-care antiseptic be determined. We therefore tested a range of normal and commensal isolates of the type found on skin. The result suggested that tea tree oil may be useful in removing transient skin flora while suppressing but maintaining resident flora.

Treatment of E. coli suspensions with tea tree oil or components resulted in significant reductions in optical density. These results suggested that the membrane was a site of action in E. coli. Other experiments showed that genetic material was being lost from bacterial cells through damage to the membrane. C. albicans cells were not lysed with terpinen-4-ol treatment and by electron microscopy, appeared unaltered. In contrast, E. coli cells appeared as empty "ghost" cells by electron microscopy. The appearance of terpinen-4-ol S. aureus also suggested damage to the cell membrane or wall. The original premise, that tea tree oil and/or its components act on the cell membrane or wall, was confirmed. While further evidence is required to corroborate these observations, the possibility that other sites of action may exist, must be considered.

Implications  This project has firmly established that tea tree oil has significant antimicrobial activity. The results have been published in mainstream medical and scientific journals and generated considerable interest in Australia and, in particular, Europe and the United States. The industry now has a firm basis for the next step in the promotion of tea tree oil as a bona fide topical antibiotic. This is to establish that tea tree oil products work in the clinical setting. To do this randomised clinical trials will need to be conducted at appropriate testing centres. This is an expensive exercise, however, the potential benefits to the industry should justify the outlay.
Project Title Herbicides for weed control in tea tree oil plantations
RIRDC Project No.: DAN-74A
Researcher:  Tony Cook
Organisation: NSW Agriculture
Tamworth Centre for Crop Improvement
Calala Lane
TAMWORTH NSW 2340
Phone: 02 6763 1100
Fax: 02 6763 1222
Objectives To develop effective herbicidal weed control practices for Australian tea tree oil plantations and ensure new herbicide recommendations do not affect quality of oil.
Background Tea tree oil is extracted from an Australian native species Melaleuca alternifolia. Weed control is considered the major problem by growers. In 1990, there were only four legalised herbicide treatments available and subsequently left growers with very expensive and limited weed control options. In addition, there is a need to maintain high production and quality of tea tree oil. Clearly there will be a need to guarantee any new recommended treatments do not contaminate the oil with herbicide residues.
Research  A survey was conducted to determine the major weed species and the techniques used to control these weeds. In addition, 65 herbicides were screened for a range of tea tree growth stages, in order to identify treatments that were safe to tea tree, provided adequate weed control and were not too cost prohibitive.
Outcomes  Approximately 80% of growers surveyed stated that weeds are a major limitation to production and half were dissatisfied with their current weed control techniques. The five most abundant weeds were kidney weed (Dichondra repens), carpet grass (Axonopus affinis), sedges (Cyperus spp.) fleabane (Conyza spp) and couch grass (Cynodon dactylon). It was shown that the majority of competition from weeds occurred in the first month after planting. A 97% reduction in yield was a consequence of high weed densities in the first few months after planting.

There are now eighteen registered treatments with all but one being Pesticide Order treatments. In some cases, recommended treatments arising from this project are 80% cheaper that previously recommended treatments and exhibit little difference in weed control and safety. There was no detectable level of herbicide residue in oil samples from tea trees treated with some of the new recommended treatments.

A weeds identification and weed control booklet will transfer information gained from this project to relevant people and will be published in 1996.

Implications  A minimum of $1,100 per hectare can be returned to growers in weedy situations by adopting the results of this project. Apart from these financial gains, new recommendations will allow for increased managerial choices, superior weed control and less likelihood of developing herbicide resistance.

Growers will possess better weed identification skills as a result of the advisory booklet and will be best advised to solve a particular weed problem.

Although considerable cost savings were made with new treatments (blanket applied), there are further savings and benefits if the practice of directed spraying was properly developed. This could allow the use of herbicides normally damaging to tea trees.

Project Title Insect pest management in tea tree
RIRDC Project No.: DAN-91A
Researchers:  Mr Gus Campbell
Organisation: NSW Agriculture
PO Box 72
ALSTONVILLE NSW 2477
Phone: 02 6628 0604
Fax: 02 6628 5209
Objectives To develop an effective sustainable pest management strategy for the Pyrgo beetle and other pests of tea tree by:

· correlating the incidence of Pyrgo in the field with weather parameters, and refining the maximum temperature threshold values for larval and egg survival to account for field observations and to improve predictive modelling;

· evaluating a monitoring procedure for detecting Pyrgo in the field; and

· screening selected insecticides and other chemicals for efficacy against Pyrgo in the laboratory and the field.

Background The tea tree industry of northern NSW and southern Queensland has developed over the last 20 years from a fledgling cottage industry into a substantial producer of some 260 tonnes of tea tree oil per annum. The early industry was based on bush harvesting but has now progressed to one of plantation culture using improved cultivars on more than 4,000 ha. Although the industry faces a number of problems, one of the more important affecting production is caused by a number of insect pests - the major one being Pyrgo beetle.

Insect problems are recognised and acknowledged by most growers, but little is known about the ecology of Pyrgo, and this has limited the development and implementation of appropriate control strategies. The industry has been promoted as being "clean and green", implying minimal or no use of insecticides, but this is belied by the substantial evidence (residues in the oil) showing that unregistered insecticides have been used on many crops. This is partly caused by the paucity of insecticides (only one is registered for use in NSW) legally available to growers, and there is clearly the need for a range of products to be available for use. 

If rational insect control strategies are to be developed and implemented for the industry, then it is important to have a better understanding of the ecology of the pests concerned. Once this is established, potential insecticide and other control measures can then be devised and evaluated.

Research  Considerable field and laboratory research has been undertaken over the last three years to investigate the various factors which, collectively, result in loss of foliage and oil production. These have included studies on the ecology of the insects concerned, on the development of systems for monitoring the first occurrence and incidence of insects in plantations, on screening cultivars for insect resistance, and on evaluating a range of insecticides and other chemicals for potential use in chemical control strategies. This latter activity was instigated part of the way through the project, when insecticide residues were detected in oil - from crops clearly treated (illegally) with insecticides not registered for the purpose.
Outcomes  There is now an excellent understanding of the ecology of Pyrgo and some of the other insects which also cause yield losses. A practical monitoring system based on sticky yellow traps has been developed and this will allow the more rational application of control strategies including the reduction in use of insecticide treatments. Several alternative insecticides have been evaluated, and been shown to provide more effective control than the current sole product (methomyl).
Implications  Growers now have a better understanding of the population dynamics of Pyrgo, and of the importance of other insect pests such as mites and psyllids. With the development of improved monitoring using sticky yellow traps, there is now the opportunity to detect the presence of Pyrgo earlier than on-plant inspections, to allow the identification of localised areas of beetle activity, and to reduce insecticide costs by rationalising their use. There may be an added opportunity for the industry to employ scouts to undertake this monitoring and to advise growers on the need to use insecticide treatments.

Illegal use of non-registered insecticides is a potential "time bomb" that, if not addressed quickly, will seriously harm the industry. Several potential insecticide products have been evaluated and found to be more effective than the current permitted product, methomyl. Steps should be taken urgently to secure their registration for use on tea tree.

This project has highlighted the need for further research on control of mites and psyllids, and on the screening of insecticides to determine their potential for leaving residues in oil.

Project Title Towards non-chemical control of weeds in tea tree
RIRDC Project No.: US-20A
Researchers:  Dr BG Sutton, Dr RD Cousins and Dr J Murtagh
Organisation: University of Sydney
GOONELLABAH NSW 2480
Phone: 02 9692 2050 
Fax: 02 9692 4172 
Objectives
· To survey tea tree growers to establish the range of weed problems encountered, and the scope of current weed control techniques used in tea tree cultivation.

· To identify the mechanisms by which weeds inhibit the growth and oil production of established tea tree plantations.

· To define practical methods of weed control for plantation managers, which minimise the use of herbicides.

Background The perception of the tea tree industry is that weeds inhibit plantation production in two phases - establishment and regrowth. 

The extent to which weeds affect the regrowth of tea tree by competing for light, nutrients and water has not been quantified, but the industry perception is that it is a real but variable problem. It is postulated that weed problems are linked to loss of fine roots of tea tree following coppicing. In these situations, the tea tree plant has weakened competitive ability against rapidly growing annual weeds until regrowth has been well established. The use of herbicides, as is currently practiced, is seen as damaging to the image of the product (tea tree oil), by growers and potential consumers. A range of cultural practices additionally used by growers, could form the basis of a non-chemical system of weed control in plantations. 

This study seeks to evaluate these alternatives. The information gained should provide guidance on when weed control is required during the regrowth cycle, and what the method used must achieve if it is to be successfully adopted. 

Research  A wide range of pot and field experiments were conducted to provide more information on the nature of root and top growth in coppiced tea trees, to allow a better understanding of the physiology of the crop in competition with weeds at different stages of its regrowth. The response to nitrogen nutrition was also examined.

Concurrently, other studies were undertaken to determine the effectiveness of various weed control strategies such as herbicide use (overall and strip treatments), cover crops, mowing, mechanical cultivation, and hand hoeing. These trials were undertaken at several localities over a three year period.

Outcomes  The results of these studies showed that weeds reduced tea tree leaf yields by an average 27% (range 9 to 47), but without affecting oil concentration or quality. This loss in yield is associated with competition for light, water and nutrients (especially nitrogen).

Two features of the regrowth cycle of tea tree are thought to be relevant to the crop’s competitiveness after harvest: the first, "coppice vigour" (the high relative growth rate of new shoots from the cut stump) increases the crop’s ability to compete for light; while the second, death of fine roots about halfway through the regrowth cycle, reduces the crop’s ability to compete for water and nutrients in the latter half of the regrowth cycle.

When all weed control strategies were compared, herbicides continued to provide the most effective control, while mechanical cultivation was the best of the non-chemical methods. Other strategies used by the industry may also be effective, but they need to be assessed against these two standards.

Implications  While the use of herbicides still provides the most effective method of weed control, non-chemical methods can also be used but, irrespective of the method selected, it is imperative that it be implemented in the latter half of the regrowth cycle when competition from weeds is greatest.
Project Title Breeding and selection of Australian tea tree for improved oil yield and quality
RIRDC Project No.: DAN-87A
Researchers:  John Murtagh Gary Baker John Doran
Organisation: Agric. Water Man. NSW Agriculture CSIRO 
Wollongbar Ag. Inst. PO Box E4008
WOLLONGBAR KINGSTON
NSW 2477 ACT 2604
Phone: (Gary Baker) 02 6626 1104 (John Doran) 02 6281 8319
Fax: 02 6628 3264 02 6281 8266
Email:  bakerg@agric.nsw.gov.au John.Doran@ffp.csiro.au
Objectives
· To select and breed seed for economic gains in oil characteristics. Gains in yield and quality are considered essential if the Australian tea tree industry is to prosper against overseas competition and the downward pressure on oil prices.
Background The Australian tea tree industry has developed from bush production to plantation production. Seed for planting is collected from natural populations using only rudimentary selection to ensure that oil quality meets industry standards. The yields of oil from plantations are variable; there is much scope to improve both the amount and quality of the yield.
Research  During the first three years of the project (1993-1996), seven field trials were established to determine the genetic variability in oil yield and quality. Two of these trials were then developed as seed orchards to provide improved seed to the industry. A natural stand of 783 trees was sampled, trees were analysed and ranked for oil concentration, terpinen-4-ol and cineole. Selecting the best 74 trees for seed production provides a selection pressure of >1:10. This ratio will enable genetic gain for selected traits. 

A progeny trial of 204 families will be further tested for oil characteristics, superior trees selected and inferior trees culled to prevent them breeding with superior trees. The superior trees will grow on and flower to produce genetically improved seed. The coppicing ability of families grown at different sites will also be used to select superior families in the orchard.

Outcomes  Variation of key commercial traits were significant at the provenance, family and individual tree levels. Heritability (narrow sense) was high (0.51) for oil concentration, moderate (0.37) for cineole% and low for the growth parameters of plant height (0.21) and stem diameter (0.14). No adverse genetic correlations were found between oil concentration and plant height and diameter. 

The performance of families across two sites (family x site interaction) was reasonably consistent, indicating that it will be possible to select families with good general adaptability in a single breeding population, thus avoiding the extra cost of establishing multiple breeding populations in different environments. 

The best performing provenances were identified and seed from these areas will be released to the industry. The controlled pollinations in 1995 have produced seeds, indicating that the methodology used has potential.

Implications  All the indicators from the first phase of breeding point to very substantial economic gains being achieved by the breeding project. Three years is a very short time in tree breeding and more time is needed to produce the much improved seed required to ensure the successful development and survival of this industry.
Publications Doran, J. C. (1995). Estimating seed quantities for tea tree plantations. Australian Tea Tree Industry Association Newsletter, April 1995.

Doran, J. C., Baker, G. R., Murtagh, G. J. Williams, E. R. and Morris, S. G. (1996). "Breeding and selection of Australian Tea Tree for improved oil yield and quality 1993 to 1996" Review Report for the Rural Industries Research And Development Corporation and the Australia Tea Tree Industry Association.

Doran, J. C., Baker, G. R., Murtagh, G. J. and Southwell, I. A. (1996). "Breeding and selection of Australian Tea Tree for improved oil yield and quality" Final Report for Rural Industries Research And Development Corporation.

Project Title Significance of cineole for the bioactivity and irritancy of tea tree oil
RIRDC Project No.: DAN-104A
Researcher:  Dr Ian Southwell
Organisation: NSW Agriculture
Wollongbar Institute
WOLLONGBAR NSW 2477
Phone: 02 6626 1224
Fax: 02 6628 3264
Objectives
· To increase the market demand for tea tree oil by measuring and documenting data on the skin irritancy and minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of different grades of tea tree oil that might be required by regulatory bodies like the USFDA for monograph acceptance.
Background Approximately 200 tonnes of tea tree oil, valued (farm gate) at $10m, are currently produced in Australia per annum. The product is used as an antimicrobial antiseptic oil or formulated into value added creams, shampoos, soaps, mouthwashes, toothpastes etc. A significant rural industry is being established around the propagation, production, processing, formulation and marketing of tea tree, the oil and its products. Plantations are expected to yield 400 tonnes pa by the late 1990s.

However, one factor hindering the broadening of the tea tree oil market base is that oil reach in cineole is considered to be of high skin irritancy and therefore not of a marketable standard.

Research  Standard clinical procedures were used to test cineole and tea tree oil for skin irritancy. Twenty five human subedits were subjected to occlusive patch testing applied to the upper arm or back for five days per week for three consecutive weeks. The patch was removed at 24 hour intervals and any skin reaction noted. Subjects reacting allergically to the test substances were withdrawn from the irritancy trial and were used in further testing for allergic reaction to individual components or fractions.

More than 20 strains of bacteria were used to test numerous tea tree oils with varying levels of cineole concentration for antimicrobial activity.

Outcomes and Implications  The results of this research have major implications for the industry. Some years ago, oils with 5-10% cineole were perfectly acceptable in the marketplace. In recent years though, buyers have been seeking oils with less than 5% and sometimes less than 3%.

This research shows clearly that there are no grounds for promoting low cineole oils other than for avoiding low terpinen-4-ol oils. If all buyers could be convinced of this, more tea tree oil could be offered for sale, providing a yield boost to many producers.

The results of the project should aid the marketing of tea tree oil. It documents: 1) the absence of skin irritancy for formulated preparations; 2) the non-allergenic nature of most tea tree oil constituents; 3) methods for the removal of some possible allergens; 4) a wider range of tea tree oil-susceptible microorganisns; 5) specific MIC values for a range of oils; and 6) enhanced MIC values for specific oils.

Project Title Developing the North Queensland tea tree industry
RIRDC Project No.: DAQ-184A
Researcher:  James Drinnan
Organisation: Queensland Department of Primary Industries
PO Box 1054
MAREEBA QLD 4880
Phone: 07 4092 8555
Fax: 07 4092 3593
Objectives
· To facilitate the rapid development of the knowledge base on the production of tea tree oil in the Mareeba Dimbulah Irrigation Area, Qld.

· To develop guidelines for irrigation scheduling for maximising oil yield and quality.

· To establish a gene pool of selected superior plants.

Background Tea tree oil production is a relatively new industry on the Atherton Tablelands in North Queensland. Interest in tea tree oil production was generated as an alternative crop for tobacco. The production systems being used now are based on New South Wales information, use high densities, and are irrigated. Due to differences in climate and soil types it is essential to adapt the findings from New South Wales research work for North Queensland conditions. Environmental and management effects, particularly irrigation, look to have a major impact on oil yields.
Research  Information on tea tree production has been gathered from key researchers working with tea tree. A soil moisture monitoring system (Environscan) has been used to investigate water use and water requirements of tea trees in North Queensland. Data has been collected on oil quality and quantity and the factors affecting it. Several seedlings have been identified as having superior oil concentration and quality. Superior planting material has also been sourced from the tea tree breeding program and is being evaluated at two locations in the Mareeba Dimbulah Irrigation Area.
Outcomes  Information was presented to growers via field days, newsletters, progress reports, presentations at growers' meetings and farm visits.

Irrigation scheduling guidelines have been developed. Mature trees use 0.8-1.0 times the pan evaporation rate which is equivalent to a total water requirement of I OML/ha/year or 7.5ML/ha/year when rainfall is subtracted.

Major factors influencing oil concentration and hence yields identified include genotype, time of year, nutrition, irrigation, and seedling vs coppice growth.

Implications  This project has helped with the very successful development of the North Queensland tea tree oil industry. There has been a rapid expansion of the industry and yields and oil quality have been excellent

 


 
Navigation Icons
Site map
Contact us
Feedback
Links
Disclaimer
Privacy Statement


Last updated: 2 August 2000
Copyright © RIRDC
http://www.rirdc.gov.au/comp00/tto1.htm