![]() |
|
Download full report (2.8meg)
Summary of full report
The Health Benefits of
Traditional Chinese Plant Medicines:
Weighing the scientific evidence
by Graeme E. Thomson
February 2007
RIRDC Publication No 06/128 RIRDC Project No DAV-227A
Who is the report targeted
at?
This report is aimed at
growers, researchers and investors as a reference of supporting science-based
medical evidence on a range of medicinal plants.
Background
Plants have always been
a source of medicine and a major resource for human health care. Chinese
traditional medicine has documented the use of botanicals for over 2,000
years. Natural products and mainly plants (greater than 80%) are the basis
of traditional Chinese medicine. About 500 species are commonly prescribed
by Chinese medical practitioners but up to 2,000 plants have a history
of recorded use. The scientific study of substances used medicinally by
different ethnic or cultural groups is viewed by researchers as an increasingly
relevant and important source of new medicinal products. Chinese medicinal
herbals make up a large proportion of the over US$15 billion annual worldwide
sales of natural medicines.
Chinese medicines have been developed to treat all important diseases including chronic ailments. In Australia the most important of these include coronary heart disease, stroke, cancer, diabetes, arthritis, dementia and respiratory disease (including asthma). Total health expenditure (around 10% of gross domestic product) is an increasing burden on the Australian economy and one that continues to increase with pressure from an ageing population.
Studies show that 60% of Australian consumers have spent some of their health dollars on supplements and natural remedies. In 2004, Australians spent AU$1.8 billion on complementary medicines and therapies. There is a willingness to believe that some of these ‘alternative remedies’ may be effective options to mainstream Western treatments.
Methods used
All the screened literature
pertaining to human health effects was science-based and published either
in recognised science and medical journals, or review text books. Scientific
and medical data were primarily sourced from the PubMed electronic database
which also covers relevant Chinese journals.
Results from human trials were given most weight in evaluation.
The study considered around 500 Asian medicinal plant species and directly reviewed and documented information on over 400 with links to some of Australia’s chronic diseases. Ninety-eight percent of these were higher plants (ie. angiosperms and gymnosperms). Over 3,500 scientific reference items were reviewed and over 1,000 of these were directly referenced in species summaries. There were more species (around 165) associated with anticancer effects than any other chronic disease, suggesting that if Asian and in particular Chinese medicinal species are to make new impacts on human health in Australia, there is a strong chance that this will be as anticancer agents.
Results
There is a general lack
of human efficacy testing associated with the use of most Asian medicinal
plants. Conclusive positive human results from randomised, double blind,
placebo-controlled experiments were only available for a limited number
of crops. Table 1. below lists existing Australian commercial crops that
are important Chinese medicinal plants with strong support from medical
efficacy trials. Many are relatively small, new crops in Australia. However,
given the strength of their efficacy data and the considerable recent Australian
investment (research and economic) that most of these plants have attracted,
there are good opportunities to develop these into much more important
commercial crops.
Table 1: Existing Australian
commercial crops with supporting medical efficacy trial data
Recommendations
Table 2: Existing crops that
require human trial testing
Table 3. Current ornamentals
grown in Australia that could be developed for medicinal properties
Table 4: Potential
‘new’ commercial crops for Australian producers that are supported by good
efficacy data
Table 5: Australian indigenous
species with potential medicinal properties
![]()
|