Monitoring Falls
During Eventing
Establishment of a national
surveillance system to monitor injury to riders and horses from falls
during the cross-country phase of eventing in Australia
by Raymond A. Cripps and
Denzil O’Brien
Flinders University
December 2004
RIRDC Publication No 04/171
RIRDC Project No UF-10A
Executive Summary
During 1999 and 2000, a
marked increase in the number of rider deaths associated with the sport
of eventing (both in Australia and overseas) focused attention on rider
safety. At the same time, the number of claims made on the Equestrian Federation
of Australia’s (EFA’s) national member accident insurance policy also highlighted
the relatively high cost of injuries incurred in activities associated
with horses. There has been no collection of data on the health, social
or financial costs of such injuries. If the equestrian community is to
develop policies for prevention and management of these injuries, and their
associated costs, accurate data are needed on which to base such policy
development, and any strategic directions for equestrian associations and
interested medical/health bodies.
With funding from the Rural
Industries Research & Development Corporation and the EFA, a pilot
project was conducted during the 2001 eventing season to see if monitoring
of falls and their injuries during the cross-country phase of eventing
was feasible. The study was conducted in New South Wales and South Australia
and involved collecting data from 29 EFA and Fédération Equestre
Internationale (FEI) affiliated events.
The results of the pilot
project undertaken during the 2001 eventing season demonstrated that procedures
and instruments developed and refined during the project to collect data
on falls and injuries during the cross-country phase of eventing were suitable
for a national surveillance system to monitor falls and their injuries.
The data collected during the pilot were able to determine the extent of
the injury problem associated with falls during eventing in New South Wales
and South Australia and to provide detailed information about riders and
their falls—essential for a surveillance system.
Before this project, no research
program existed in Australia to monitor horse-related injury during eventing.
The procedures and instruments developed during the pilot formed the basis
of a national surveillance program to monitor falls associated with eventing,
to determine the extent of the injury problem can be determined nationally.
Such a program enables changes in frequency of falls and of rider and horse
injuries to be characterised and monitored over time. Such information
is essential to inform other injury prevention projects and to develop
counter-measures to reduce falls and injuries during eventing.
With the support of the EFA
and the National Eventing Committee, funding was approved by RIRDC to set
up and implement a surveillance system to monitor falls and fall-related
injuries to riders and horses at all FEI and EFA affiliated events in Australia.
This program began in February 2002 (commencement of the 2002 eventing
season) and was conducted in all States over a two-year period.
A summary of major
highlights are:
-
Six hundred and thirty-six falls
were reported involving 459 riders who had one fall and 177 other riders
who had multiple falls (two to five or more falls) during the reporting
periods.
-
Eighty-six horses fell, with
horses in age group 5 to 9 years most at risk of falling.
-
Thirty-six per cent of horses
which fell had successfully completed five or fewer cross-country courses.
-
Riders aged 15 to 19 years demonstrated
a higher rate of falling and accounted for 27% of the falls.
-
Eighty-nine per cent of riders
who fell began riding before the age of 15 years and, on average, had completed
70 one-day events (ODEs). At this time, details on riders who did not fall
are not available.
-
Twenty-eight per cent of riders
who fell had one or more injuries (at home, during schooling or competition)
during the last 12 months.
-
For the riders who fell, the
majority seemed to perceive the risk of injury to be a moderate one particularly
when they had experienced one or more injuries. Perceived risk increased
as injuries increased.
-
The incident rate of falls was
1.2 falls per 1000 jumping efforts for all classes and jurisdictions monitored
during 2002 and 2003.
-
Rate of falls increased exponentially
with competition level from the Pre-novice to the Advanced class, possibly
as a result of to the increase in the number of jumping efforts at the
higher levels.
-
Rate of falls of horses was
very low (2 falls per 10,000 jumping efforts), about one-sixth the rate
of riders.
-
Of the 636 riders who fell (fall
details reported at time of writing), 34% reported fall-related injuries
-
Injury to the upper body region
(head, neck, shoulders and upper limbs) was reported in 43% of the injured
riders, with the head and neck accounting for half of these injuries.
-
Head injuries, fractures and
internal injuries accounted for 22% of injuries reported and resulted in
riders presenting to a hospital emergency department for treatment. Ten
were admitted to hospital.
-
Twenty-nine per cent of riders
injured had no limitations on their daily activities following injury,
about one-half had some limitations (from less than one day to more than
21 days).
-
Thirty-nine of the 89 horses
that fell were reported injured (69% minor injuries, mainly abrasions,
lacerations or bruising). More serious injuries such as tendon damage,
muscle damage or fractures were reported in 11 horses.